As writing instructors, we have spent a great deal of time thinking about ChatGPT, its abilities and inabilities, and how it may impact students’ learning and their development of writing and critical thinking skills. We do not think outsourcing aspects of the writing process to ChatGPT or other generative artificial intelligence (genAI) programs is wise for students.
A non-exhaustive rationale:
Most importantly, ChatGPT and other generative AI tools allow students to forgo basic steps in the writing process. Studying and practicing these basic steps make students better, more confident writers and thinkers. Steps like generating ideas, planning, and engaging in the reiterative process of writing, thinking, rethinking, and rewriting promotes critical thinking and learning, which is what university writing assignments are designed to do. When a technology completes these steps in whole or in substantial part for students, they are deprived of the cognitive growth associated with driving the process themselves.
There are also substantial problems with the writing these tools produce, which stymies the usefulness of genAI as a co-writing tool for students. Though completely grammatically correct, AI-generated text is often vague, bland, and repetitive. Generative AI is untrustworthy as a source of information; the text it produces contains inaccuracies and lacks sources. And because novice writers are typically not well-positioned to adopt these tools critically and make meaningful revisions to computer-generated text while retaining authorship and ownership of it, we think it is a tool that robs students of more than it offers them in their learning process.
As such, the Writing Centre will not encourage student use of ChatGPT/genAI as part of their writing process, or to help them learn to use it.
However, many students will understandably be curious about genAI and want to experiment with it. To help orient students to what artificial intelligence is and help them think critically about it, the Writing Centre has developed a short Moodle module (“Aritifical Intelligence & CBU Students”). The module emphasizes students’ responsibility for understanding and following faculty policies on use/non-use of generative AI in completing their academic work. You may wish to review it and assign it to your students to read.
At the Writing Centre this term, we are prepared, as ever, to help students develop their writing skills and gain confidence in their abilities. This includes helping them recognize features of strong writing, consider the quality of the writing genAI produces, and make ethical choices that support their learning.
Fall 2023